The Benefits of Setting Yourself Apart

Jan. 1, 2020
Attracting and retaining good employees is never easy. But the right benefits package can make working for your shop more appealing. Here are some ways to spruce up your employee benefits-often without spending a lot of money.
Attracting and retaining good employees is never easy. But the right benefits package can make working for your shop more appealing. Here are some ways to spruce up your employee benefits-often without spending a lot of money.It's virtually impossible to attend any gathering of shop owners without hearing some discussion about employees. The shop owners who aren't having trouble finding good employees are worried about hanging on to the ones they have. For many shop owners, finding and keeping good employees are daily concerns.Attracting top-quality employees and developing their loyalty is very similar to marketing to customers. The key is to set yourself apart from the competition. There's no shortage of ways to set yourself apart from other employers, just as you can compete for customers in any number of ways. Some employees are looking for better working conditions, a chance for advancement, a job close to home or the opportunity to work for one of the area's "best" shops. For others, it's the bottom line-their paychecks are their first and foremost concern.But one of the most cost-effective ways to set your shop apart in the minds of employees and potential employees is with the benefits package you offer. The right combination of good working conditions and a unique, attractive benefits package can often lure top technicians, even if a shop up the street is offering higher per-hour pay.The beauty of many employee perks or benefits is that they don't have to cost an arm and a leg to have impact. Often, some of the least expensive employee extras are the ones they most appreciate and that do the most for their overall job satisfaction. It's just like the customer who picks up his car after a $3,500 repair-and comes back to thank you for cleaning the interior. Little things count.Here's some information on a wide range of employee benefits that collision repair shops and other small businesses around the country are offering. Some may be better suited to this industry than others. And some may sound just plain strange at first. But think about an idea before you disregard it: Offering something different from every other shop in your area might be what helps you find those top-notch techs and what keeps them from moving on to your competitor.Shake up the ScheduleOne shop owner swears he could drop his group medical plan, reduce the number of paid vacation days and stop handing out end-of-year bonuses and still not lose an employee. Why? Because, he says, he's found the one thing his employees want most: three-day weekends.The shop's crew works nine-hour days-allowing the shop to extend the hours it is open for customers-but everyone gets every other Friday off. Having only half the team on Fridays occasionally results in some confusion or problems, the shop owner reports, but the schedule is so popular that everyone pitches in to cover the bases. Productivity has held steady and is often higher than it was under the old 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. schedule.Join the ClubProviding employees with free or discounted memberships is something that can benefit their families, too. Look into business or group membership rates at nearby health clubs, warehouse shopping clubs, or golf and sports clubs.Finding a credit union your employees can join may help them get loans, no-fee checking and savings accounts, and direct deposit of payroll checks. This is a benefit that usually won't cost your business a dime. To locate a credit union, check your local phone book. In addition to a list of area credit unions, you may also find a listing for a credit union league or association that can help you find a credit union you qualify for.That's the TicketWith movie ticket prices topping $9 and $10 in many areas, taking the family out for a weekend evening isn't cheap. Offering free or discounted movie tickets can be an extremely popular employee benefit. Call a local theater chain to find out about buying tickets in bundles-often at half the regular price. You can give the tickets to employees or just offer them at the discounted price.You may also be able to obtain group discounted tickets for concerts, theater productions, sporting events, auto shows and other local events. Getting your employees out of the shop as a group for an evening or Saturday event can help build morale and camaraderie, especially when the boss picks up the tab.Also check into the availability of discounted group tickets for local college or professional sporting events. A number of shops have found their employees prefer a company night at the ballpark with their families to the traditional company picnic, and this is often easier and less expensive for the company.If you have an active group of employees, challenge other shops to a softball tournament, or sponsor an employee bowling team. (The right uniforms also offer some advertising benefits.)Rent a van or mini-bus to take a group on a ski trip or to a nearby lake, beach or resort. Look into a river cruise. Or just treat everyone to a dinner out, whether it's pizza or prime rib.One word of caution here: Spending an evening with the boss may not be viewed as a benefit to all employees. Consider making any shop group activity optional, so that no one feels you're intruding on their free time.Help Them Prepare to RetireSetting up a retirement plan for your employees may not be as complicated or expensive as you may think, and you may find that it actually helps you save more for your future and reduce your tax bill now.A traditional 401(k) plan allows employees to put up to 15 percent of their pre-tax pay (up to $10,500 a year) into an investment account, choosing from a number of different types of investments included in the program. As an employer, you can choose if you want to match some percentage of their regular contributions, contribute a lump-sum of year-end profits or neither.The employee owns any money they contribute to the plan, but you can establish how long they have to work for you to be vested, or own, the money you contribute to their accounts. The amount of your pre-tax income you can put aside in such a plan is based on how much your employees contribute.The fees for this type of plan can be a little high, especially for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. You may instead want to consider a Simplified Employee Pension (SEP) or Savings Incentive Match Plans for Employees (SIMPLE), which as their names imply, are generally simpler and less expensive to set up and maintain. These plans do require the employer to contribute a set percentage of every employee's wages to their accounts, but you can change that percentage from year to year with the SEP.According to a 1998 study, about one in three collision shops offer employees a retirement plan. That's almost twice the number that did just three years earlier, so the percentage is probably even higher now. But if you're not convinced it's a benefit worth investing in, you could still offer employees some retirement planning help by asking your personal financial adviser to offer them some lunchtime mini-seminars or free consultations.At Your ServiceCheck with the service providers you work with to see if there are ways they could help your employees at little or no cost to you. Let employees know, for example, that you offer a free initial consultation with a financial planner, tax preparer, real estate agent, stock broker or accountant.An employee assistance program (EAP) is another way to help your workers receive free, confidential help with problems that are affecting them while they are at work. Available through some trade associations (or check the phone book under "Employee Assistance Programs"), EAPs allow employees covered under the program to dial one hotline to receive help with family and relationship concerns, drug and alcohol dependence, depression, financial crises and other personal pressures. The EAP staff may provide counseling services or may serve as a clearinghouse of information, guiding the employee to resources available-often at little or no cost-for their particular situation. Employers are not told when their employees use the program.Shops enrolled in an EAP pay an annual per-employee fee-often under $50. That small investment may help shop owners keep good employees who may be having some difficult personal problems, and it keeps you from having to become an amateur social worker if employees bring such problems to you.Give Your Medical Plan a TwistTry to offer a medical plan that best fits your employee's needs. If most of them are single, offering family coverage might not be seen as a real benefit. On the other hand, if most are married, they might be willing to live with a higher deductible in order to have their families covered.Dental and vision plans, though sometimes expensive, are other extras that your competitors may not offer. If these are coverages you feel employees would appreciate, consider adding them, and perhaps raise your medical deductible to help offset the additional cost.Also ask your insurance carrier about discounts available for an employee wellness program. This may make it more economical for you to offer family coverage to those meeting low-risk criteria (such as non-obese, non-smokers).You might also look into dropping your traditional health insurance plan and switching to medical savings accounts (MSAs). Under most MSAs, the employer buys a catastrophic health insurance plan to cover workers' medical costs. It might have a deductible of $3,000, meaning it wouldn't pay anything until a worker's medical costs surpassed that amount in any given year. But after that, everything would be covered.The employer then sets aside $2,000 in each employee's MSA. If a worker gets sick, the bills are paid from his or her MSA as long as it lasts. If the bills surpass $2,000, the employee would have to pay up to $1,000 out of pocket until the catastrophic policy kicks in. Under the plan, the employee may be able to receive any cash left in their MSA at the end of the year, or they may be able to roll it over to let the account build up for the future.Proponents of MSAs say they give the individual more freedom and personal responsibility because they can use health care providers of their choice. They say people make better health care choices when they control the purse strings. But opponents argue that some employees make poor care decisions because of the promise of getting cash back.You'll want to talk to your accountant about any state laws or tax implications involved with switching to an MSA plan. MSAs can be confusing for employees at first, too, so make sure you receive the printed materials and other help you need to explain it thoroughly.Spruce Up the Employee LunchroomJust as the cleanliness and professionalism of your front office can have a big impact on how customers view your business, the type of employee lunchroom you provide sends a message to your workers about how you feel about them.It doesn't have to be fancy, but keep it clean and adequately furnished. Consider providing a refrigerator, microwave or coffee pot if you don't already. If you already provide these, consider picking up the tab for a higher-quality coffee-upgrading from Folger's to Starbuck's won't cost a lot but may really be appreciated. A water cooler can be a nice plus and can help encourage employees to replenish liquids on those hot days in the shop.Sign Up NowCheck out the autobody classified section of your local paper, and you may find that some shop has latched onto a method that many businesses use to lure top talent: the signing bonus. Once we hire you and you move in your toolbox, the ads state, you receive a check for $500 or more. The up-front cash attracts attention and can be money well spent if the shop receives more and better applicants with fewer ads.Again, a signing bonus can make coming to work for you more appealing than the other shops advertising for help and might convince a top-notch technician that it's worth a little longer commute or a little less per hour to work for you rather than someone else.Caring for Young and OldWhile primarily only larger companies now offer much in the way of child care or elder care, this is changing. Being among the first shops to offer such benefits could be to your advantage.Finding and funding adequate care for children or for ailing parents can be a tremendous burden, one that can affect employee performance. Employers can assist in a number of ways. At the inexpensive end is offering resources or referral services that help employees find the care they need. Other businesses take it a step further and pay for or subsidize such care.Vacationing in a Bank?One employee might like to forego his second week of vacation in order to have some extra money to spend on the trip he wants to take during his first week of vacation. Another employee might like a third week of vacation this year because he has a new baby at home.Vacation banks can help out both of these employees. Vacation banks allow an employee who wants more time off to "buy" it from the company. If an employee would rather have some cash, he can sell vacation time back.Some businesses also combine vacation time and sick time and lump it together into paid time off (PTO). Employees can use PTO as they choose, without distinguishing between sick or vacation days. Hewitt Associates, a national benefits consulting firm, found in a study that the PTO plan reduces absenteeism. It also can result in savings for the business if the total amount of PTO is reduced when vacation time and sick leave are lumped together.Don't Forget about TrainingToo often, employers don't do a sufficient job communicating to employees that the training the business pays for is a true benefit. If that training helps them be more productive, everyone benefits. If that training helps the shop bring in more business (by qualifying the shop for a direct repair program (DRP), for example), everyone benefits. And if that training helps the shop meet customers' needs, everyone benefits.Set up your training benefits just as you would any other part of your budget and benefits package, and make sure it is explained in your employee handbook or policy manual. Consider offering a set amount of training or tuition assistance per year.Some shops pay for training up front. Others reimburse the employee for the training after a set period of time to avoid having an employee leave the company immediately after receiving the training.Some shops also require employees to earn a certain grade, pass the training course exam or otherwise demonstrate that they didn't just sit through the course, and others ask employees to share the information they gained with others in the shop, either in a formal or informal way.Encourage employees to let you know about training opportunities they think would be of value. And whether or not you pay for some or all employee training, you can always tie wage increases to successful completion of training or certifications.Mini-MotivatorsKeep a supply of gift certificates on hand to give to employees who go "above and beyond" their job description in order to help a customer or to ensure a job is completed. It doesn't have to be expensive-even a $5 or $10 gift certificate can buy a lunch, a couple of movie rentals, a meal's worth of groceries, ice cream cones for a family, etc. Matching the reward to the person can have an even larger impact. Get to know your employee's individual interests (golf, fishing, etc.), and use gift certificates they'll really appreciate.Help Employees Save MoneyYou can't always pay them more, but you can help them get more for their money. Work with merchants in your area to provide employees with discounted products and services. Convince your bank to offer lower-fee checking accounts. Ask a cellular phone provider to offer a special monthly discount. Arrange for discounts on tires or other automotive products not available to employees through the shop. Offer discounted newspaper subscriptions by having multiple copies delivered to the shop. Allow them to order flowers or balloon bouquets for their spouse or children with a discount from a local florist.There's even a national buying group that can help smaller businesses offer these kinds of discounts to their employees. The Illinois-based Employee Services Management Association has about 3,000 members and 50 chapters throughout the country. An annual membership fee of about $165 allows members to offer their employees discounts on a wide range of products and services-travel, admission to Disneyland, baby car seats, wedding invitation printing, etc. For more information, check out the organization's Web site at www.esmassn.org or call (630) 368-1280.Get Them Out of the ShopEmployees want to feel that they're on a winning team. Taking employees to such industry events as association meetings, trade shows and seminars can make them feel part of the bigger picture. Having a group there in "uniform"-company hats, T-shirts or jackets-can boost morale and communicate to other potential employees that your shop is among the best in the industry.Impact the FamilyYou may get more mileage from your perks if they are something an employee's spouse or family enjoys and looks forward to as well. Rather than a third week of vacation for long-term employees, why not give them airline vouchers or gift certificates for a ski lodge, casino/hotel or other resort? This can help ensure they actually take a vacation with the time off, you've cut down the time they're away from the shop, and their spouse or family will value their continued employment with you.Other benefits that may help you please good employees and their families include arranging for free or discounted house cleaning services, having fruit or food baskets delivered to their homes, offering use of your personal or company-owned condo or vacation home, and offering some flex time to allow employees to attend school other family-related events.If you're feeling overwhelmed by the number of choices available as you consider your shop's employee benefits package, help is not far away. The people who can best help you decide what will be valued are only steps away-out in your shop. Ask your employees for feedback on the benefits you currently offer and for their suggestions on changes or additions to the package. You'll find out very quickly which benefits will best help you find and keep the top employees you need to run your business.
About the Author

John Yoswick | Contributing Editor

John Yoswick is a freelance writer based in Portland, Ore., who has been writing about the automotive collision repair industry since 1988. He can be contacted by e-mail at [email protected].

Sponsored Recommendations

Best Body Shop and the 360-Degree-Concept

Spanesi ‘360-Degree-Concept’ Enables Kansas Body Shop to Complete High-Quality Repairs

ADAS Applications: What They Are & What They Do

Learn how ADAS utilizes sensors such as radar, sonar, lidar and cameras to perceive the world around the vehicle, and either provide critical information to the driver or take...

Banking on Bigger Profits with a Heavy-Duty Truck Paint Booth

The addition of a heavy-duty paint booth for oversized trucks & vehicles can open the door to new or expanded service opportunities.

Boosting Your Shop's Bottom Line with an Extended Height Paint Booths

Discover how the investment in an extended-height paint booth is a game-changer for most collision shops with this Free Guide.