Collision repair costs increase in third quarter, Mitchell says

The average vehicle crash damage repair on an adjusted basis increased $164 in the third quarter, according to Mitchell International’s 2009 special NACE Edition of its Industry Trends Report (ITR), a quarterly publication that highlights indus
Jan. 1, 2020
3 min read

The average vehicle crash damage repair on an adjusted basis increased $164 in the third quarter, according to Mitchell International’s 2009 special NACE Edition of its Industry Trends Report (ITR), a quarterly publication that highlights industry-related trends, news items and statistics.

Mitchell said in the third quarter average gross appraisal value for comprehensive coverage estimates processed through company servers was $2,468 compared to $2,356 in the same period for 2008.

Applying a development factor of 2.1 percent for this data set, the firm said, produces an adjusted value of $2,520, a $164 increase from this same period last year.
Average gross appraisal value is the average repair cost for cars damaged in an insurance claim that are going to be repaired.

Mitchell said on average, the third-quarter actual cash value of vehicles appraised for collision losses was $12,188 – $829 less than the period in 2008 – reflecting the continuing lower value of today's vehicle mix.

Actual cash value is the value of those vehicles on average before they were damaged.
Mitchell in its pricing calculations employs the Mitchell Collision Parts Price Index (MCPPI), a metric similar to the Consumer Price Index but created specifically for the collision repair industry.

The firm said it discovered that due to the substitution effect of aftermarket parts, estimate severity has deceased despite rising original equipment manufacturer part prices.
Mitchell said its MCPPI is based on the industry's most comprehensive data for the top-20 most-replaced collision parts, which can be used to assess how inflationary trends by part type impact the collision repair community.

“Comparing our supporting data from the MCPPI with trends in severity and the national rate of inflation shows that a clear substitution effect is at work, causing average gross repairable estimate severity to decline, despite rising OEM parts prices, says Greg Horn, Mitchell vice president of industry relations and author of the report "The Mitchell Collision Parts Price Index Proves the Unexpected: When OEM Part Prices Increased, Estimate Severity Decreased."

“As repairers opt to substitute more economically viable used or aftermarket parts in place of costly OEM parts in ever-larger numbers, the net effect has been a decrease in parts dollars and increase in labor dollars on repairable estimates in recent years,” Horn says. “Mitchell's data and analysis is committed to helping the collision repair industry understand these changes, and the reasons behind them, in order to help our customers compete in a constantly changing marketplace.”

The 2009 NACE edition of the ITR also includes a feature on best practices for customer satisfaction research in the collision repair industry from AutocheX, Mitchell's customer experience management group. Jason Bertellotti, Mitchell's vice president of repair solutions, discusses cultural factors that impact Hispanic satisfaction survey outcomes in the industry. With the immense growth in population and buying power of the U.S. Hispanic community, it is increasingly important to understand the collision repair experience from the Latino perspective and the issues that may affect their level of satisfaction.

Complete content is available in the latest ITR, which may be downloaded in PDF format by visiting www.mitchell.com.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Latest in Events

The Missouri Auto Body Association
Missouri Auto Body Association Association logo
This event will be hosted on February 28 in St. Louis, Missouri.
Feb. 20, 2024
TCRA
tcralogofinalfullcolor
The Tennessee Collision Repairers Association's first quarterly meeting of the year is coming this Thursday.
Feb. 19, 2024
SCRS
scrs_logo_2024
The terms of four members will expire by this April.
Feb. 15, 2024