Court: Tire Rotation Doesn't Technically Include Tightening Lug Nuts

An appeals court in Michigan has ruled that "performing" a tire rotation is, strictly speaking, moving the tires and nothing more.

Oct. 24, 2019
2 min read

Oct. 24, 2019—A pair of Michigan car owners sued a dealership in 2013 after a tire came off while driving, leading to a crash. A tech at the dealership hadn't tightened the lug nuts after a tire rotation.

The owners, one of whom was injured in the crash, won their case against the dealership and were awarded $110,000 for damages and legal costs under the Motor Vehicle Service and Repair Act.

The dealership appealed, according to a report of the case by Jalopnik. The Motor Vehicle Service and Repair Act is violated in part when a shop charges for repairs that "are not in fact performed." A Michigan appeals court decided to take a close look at what constituted "performed" in this tire rotation.

Judges ultimately concluded that the tire rotation is performed when the tires are moved, but that's where it ends. As highlighted by Jalopnik:

"We conclude, under the plain language of MCL257.1307a, that defendants 'performed' a tire rotation, albeit negligently...There is no support for the trial court’s determination that a tire rotation is not “performed” if a service person fails to sufficiently tighten the lug nuts on one tire," the ruling said.

The ruling noted that the tech had successfully moved the tires. The tech who did the rotation admitted that he placed the lug nuts back on the tire but didn't wrench them tight, which the court determined to be negligent. But a strict reading of the law prevented that to be a violation of the law.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Latest in Latest News

Enterprise/Tasco Auto Color
Enterprise and Tasco Logo
Enterprise and Tasco Auto Color continue to support the Collision Industry Foundation program at the second highest tier, Urgent Care, for donors that contribute $5,000-$10,000...
June 19, 2025
Adobe Stock 200930201
adobestock_200930201
The insurance company said it has control of its systems and hasn’t detected any evidence of ransomware or ongoing threat actor activity since the June 7 attack.
June 19, 2025
MSCRA
MSCRA Logo
The Mountain States Collision Repair Association’s first in-person event features four industry experts and networking opportunities at Downhill Brewing in Parker, Colorado.
June 19, 2025