Massachusetts Court Rules Insurers Must Pay for Inherent Diminished Value

The ruling applies to third-party claimants only. 

Oct. 21, 2021—Massachusetts auto insurers are now required to compensate third-party claimants for the lost value of a vehicle even after it has been repaired. 

According to a Claims Journal report, the state’s highest court ruled Tuesday that standard auto policies issued in Massachusetts require compensation for “inherent diminished value.”

“Because the plain language of part 4 of the standard policy does not limit recovery to merely repair or replacement costs, such recovery must compensate a claimant for any loss of value the claimant incurred as a result of a collision, offset by the increase in value that may occur from repairs to the vehicle,” the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court said in a unanimous decision written by Justice Serge Georges Jr.

The opinion does not state whether it applies to first-party claims. 

About the Author

FenderBender Staff Reporters

The FenderBender staff reporters have nearly four decades of combined journalism and collision repair experience.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Latest in Latest News

Enterprise/Tasco Auto Color
Enterprise and Tasco Logo
Enterprise and Tasco Auto Color continue to support the Collision Industry Foundation program at the second highest tier, Urgent Care, for donors that contribute $5,000-$10,000...
June 19, 2025
Adobe Stock 200930201
adobestock_200930201
The insurance company said it has control of its systems and hasn’t detected any evidence of ransomware or ongoing threat actor activity since the June 7 attack.
June 19, 2025
MSCRA
MSCRA Logo
The Mountain States Collision Repair Association’s first in-person event features four industry experts and networking opportunities at Downhill Brewing in Parker, Colorado.
June 19, 2025