BMW Fraud Class Action Suit Heads to Appeals Court

A BMW driver on Tuesday told the Ninth Circuit that the noise created by his car’s squealing brakes presents a safety concern that the company had a duty to disclose.
Feb. 15, 2018
2 min read

Feb. 15, 2018—A BMW driver on Tuesday told the Ninth Circuit that the noise created by his car’s squealing brakes presents a safety concern that the company had a duty to disclose, and implored the court to revive his fraud class action suit, according to a Law 360 report.

Plaintiff attorney Hovanes Margarian told the appellate court that a California federal judge wrongfully tossed out his putative class action alleging that the optional high-performance ceramic brakes make overly loud, squealing sounds. He claimed that BMW needed to disclose the noise, since it could be considered a safety defect that could distract those around the car.

“The description of the brakes, in my opinion, should say ‘high-performance noisy brakes.’ Then you would have disclosure,” he said. “But, if it says ‘high-performance brakes,’ then you don’t have proper disclosure.”

A U.S. District judge asked whether the noise had been linked to an accident; Margarian said that it hadn’t. BMW attorney Jeffrey Miller told the panel that vehicle owner’s manuals inform drivers that the brakes can make noise under certain conditions, and emphasized that the complaint included no allegations that the brakes didn’t function properly.

Plaintiff Norik Barakezyan initially took action against BMW in Jan. 2016, claiming that he paid nearly $9,000 extra for high-performance carbon ceramic brakes on a leased BMW M6 that squealed loudly when in use. He filed the complaint on behalf of all drivers who had certain BMW M-class vehicles with the purchased brake system.

During Miller’s arguments, U.S. Circuit Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw said that the court doesn’t know all facts in the case, given the stage that it was earlier dismissed.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Latest in Site Placement

SCRS
scrs_logo_240x100
Chairman Michael Bradshaw issues a call to action and writes that, "Governance decisions made by I-CAR could significantly impact representation within the organization and the...
June 16, 2025
SEMA
battleofthebuilders2025
All builders with a vehicle displayed at the 2025 SEMA Show may enter the competition before the deadline on October 17. Entrants across 12 categories will compete to become the...
June 16, 2025
SEMA
SEMA Logo
The Congressional Review Act resolution revoked a waiver that would have enabled California to ban internal combustion engine vehicles.
June 16, 2025