Judge Sides with Gunder, Overrules Progressive's Motion to Dismiss

March 2, 2015
2 min read

March 2, 2015—A Florida judge recently ruled in favor of shop owner Ray Gunder, overruling a motion to dismiss filed by Progressive Casualty Insurance Company in a lawsuit Gunder filed on behalf of a customer.

On Feb. 23, Judge Susan B. Flood of the County Court of the Tenth Judicial Circuit in and for Polk County, denied Progressive’s motion to dismiss the complaint and strike claim for attorney’s fees. Furthermore, the court denied Progressive’s motion and defeated the insurer’s efforts to invoke the Appraisal Clause as provided for in their policy contract.

The lawsuit was filed by Gunder, owner of Gunder’s Auto Center in Lakeland, Fla., acting on behalf of his customer. The suit accuses Progressive of failing to pay for the reasonable and necessary costs to perform repairs to Gunder’s customer’s damaged vehicle.

“This ruling is huge as it allows us to proceed with the multiple lawsuits we currently have in process on behalf of other customers who have been shortchanged by this insurer as well as other insurers who have underpaid their policyholders,” Gunder said in a release.

The lawsuits seek full payment of the underpayments, plus costs, expenses, attorney fees, prejudgment and postjudgment interest.

Gunder has also settled a lawsuit against State Farm Insurance, and has set a precedent for pursuing legal action against insurance companies on behalf of his business and customers.

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Latest in Running a Shop

Bailey Davidson
THE NEXT GENERATION: James Ivanowski's (left) oldest son, Jonah (far right) works as an estimator and is involved in most high-level decisions for the business.
Proud of their legacy, Hollingsworth Auto Service’s family owners have pivoted to meet the industry’s shifting needs.
June 17, 2025
Dave Dunn
ALWAYS BE RECRUITING: Dave Dunn has run Dave's Auto Body for nearly 50 years, and his approach to recruiting has included a 'waiting line' of viable candidates.
You can turn recruiting into your shop’s strength with just 30 minutes every quarter.
June 16, 2025
Adobe Stock 997306555
Geofencing
How digital marketing maneuvers can help keep shops top-of-mind with customers old and new.
June 13, 2025